To receive free, unrestricted access to this publication’s 500+ exclusive reports for seven days, just click the “free trial” button below. You can cancel your subscription to Proof at any time.
Introduction
Here’s everything we know:
The Treason statute reads as follows: “Whoever, owing allegiance to the United States….adheres to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort within the United States or elsewhere, is guilty of treason and shall suffer death, or shall be imprisoned not less than five years and fined under this title but not less than $10,000; and shall be incapable of holding any office under the United States.”
The United States is at war with Iran—with Israel as a co-belligerent—but Trump administration policy warns diplomats abroad, especially in Israel, that there are things Israel could do that would be expressly contrary to America’s national security interests. There’s no mystery as to what actions Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu could take that would turn Israel’s military into an adverse entity in a war the U.S. is embroiled in: (1) if Netanyahu took action to annex the West Bank, as this not only expressly violates Trump administration policy and is something Israel has promised the Trump administration it won’t do but could force the U.S. to enter a new military confrontation with new belligerents beyond those it now faces (i.e., Iran, the Houthis, and at certain points Hamas and Hezbollah, all of whom could suddenly find U.S. ally Jordan sharing key national security interests); (2) if Netanyahu were to take any action—such as the actions now being taken by U.S. adversaries Russia and China—that premeditatedly put American lives in danger.
One of President Donald Trump’s top agents in Israel is David Milstein; Trump is Milstein’s boss, and American taxpayers pay Milstein’s salary. Trump posted Milstein to Israel in April 2025, just a few weeks before the Iran War began in June 2025 (Trump now admits the war began in June 2025, not February 2026, as Proof has consistently contended, and admits that the United States remains at war 17 months later). Milstein got his posting because he worked for the Senate under Trump ally and ardent Zionist Ted Cruz (R-TX) for half a decade—making a name for himself as one of the most pro-Israel American officials in Washington. When Trump named Mike Huckabee, an Evangelical Christian minister who believes he’s called by his religion to put Israel’s interests alongside America’s—because he believes Israel must be made safe for the near-term Second Coming of Christ—Milstein was a natural choice to be Huckabee’s top adviser due to his record of viewing Israel’s security as a paramount consideration for America… at whatever cost.
The New York Times now reports that, while America was involved in active military hostilities in and around Iran with Israel as a co-belligerent, Milstein chose to adhere to the interests of the State of Israel rather than the United States by doctoring intelligence reports to obscure necessary military intelligence from the United States—in many cases erasing mission-critical national security intelligence altogether. Moreover, Milstein chose to engage in this conduct on topics he expressly knew constituted a “red line” for the United States on the question of whether America would deem Israel an allied co-belligerent or rather a hostile adversary in the Iran War. In fact, the Times found that Milstein’s conduct was premeditatedly and consistently geared toward ensuring that Israel was never seen to have crossed any red lines by U.S. officials. This means that Milstein was working clandestinely to advance an Israeli government policy even as he was working clandestinely to undermine U.S. ones he was sworn and paid to uphold.
This conduct appears to meet the definition of Treason. Worse still, it’s Treason in service of a nation American officials have previously been convicted of Espionage and sentenced to life in prison for secretly assisting. And incredibly, in those prior cases the assistance (unlike here) happened outside wartime, did not risk American lives, did not cover up American civilian deaths, and focused on transmitting intel to Israel rather than hiding intel from America (the latter being an exponentially graver offense, as America has always shared intel with the Israelis—Jonathan Pollard, for instance, “simply” shared intel America hadn’t yet shared and wouldn’t necessarily have shared—but our government has never accepted or condoned the idea of an American political appointee deliberately hiding intel from his superiors in wartime).
These Traitorous Acts Are a Massive “October Surprise”
According to the Times, “at the height of the Iran War” the Israelis—a co-belligerent with the U.S.—chose to “flout one of President Trump’s explicit red lines for Israel” (emphasis supplied) by “approv[ing] more settlements in the Israeli-occupied West Bank than it ever had at one time.” The scope of the new approvals, which the United States wasn’t told about by Netanyahu or his government, so clearly amounted to an incipient annexation of the West Bank (and therefore the possible opening of a new front in the Iran War America would have to fight in) that every American official in Israel who spoke to the Times deemed the situation an “urgent” one as a matter of American national security. The Trump administration needed to be notified of the situation immediately, in their view. That America was then in a wartime footing made the transmission of this classified intelligence to officials in Washington even more manifestly a top government priority.
But it appears two men felt differently: Trump appointees Huckabee and Milstein.
And normally such dissent would be fine—ish—as Huckabee and Milstein could easily have followed conventional diplomatic protocols and sent Washington a diplomatic cable about an “urgent” situation that included a “minority report” (i.e., an addendum written by the two men that urged Washington to not treat Israel as having crossed a national-security “red line” in the middle of a sprawling hot war in the Middle East).
But that’s not what they did.
An urgent diplomatic cable was written by U.S. diplomats in Jerusalem, intended for the eyes of President Trump, and Milstein—presumably under Huckabee’s supervision—made sure it never got sent.
That alone would seem to warrant something somewhere between (a) the firing of, (b) the firing and immediate investigation of, or (c) the arrest and detention of both men for adhering to a foreign nation in wartime when they knew its interests clashed with America’s—at a minimum, surely the two men needed to be relieved from their duties immediately and sent home for major congressional oversight hearings—but they didn’t stop there.
As the Times reports (emphasis supplied),
This was no isolated incident. Since taking up his post in April 2025, Milstein, 36, has repeatedly suppressed or significantly revised embassy reporting on Israeli activities to present the Netanyahu government in a favorable light, according to a dozen people who work with or interact with him in both Jerusalem and Washington.
But even this journalistic indictment understates the facts on the ground significantly.
Readers shouldn’t understand Milstein—a mid-thirty-something only slightly older than Justin Bieber, who looks to be running his own rogue intelligence operation in Israel—to have merely squashed urgent intel reports or doctored intel reports to show Israel in a more “favorable light” than it deserved.
Milstein premeditatedly lied to our government by telling it exactly the opposite of what was really happening on the ground in the middle of a war in which the U.S. had clear “red lines” he had been instructed on.
And those lies were intended to make the crossing of such national security red lines invisible to Washington.
As the Times reports,
Milstein and Huckabee had unmistakable evidence that the Israeli government was doing nothing to stop the mass violence committed by Israeli “settlers” in the West Bank—exactly the sort of mass violence that could open a new front in the Iran War, including by bringing belligerents not presently involved in the Iran War into it (e.g., Jordan, Syria, or the Palestinian Authority)—and Milstein instead told the U.S. government the opposite: that the Israeli government was “cracking down” on the attacks… when he well knew it was doing no such thing.
Milstein and Huckabee also had unmistakable evidence that Israeli soldiers were killing Americans, but when other officials in the embassy in Jerusalem wrote a report detailing those killings—which could have led to the United States treating Israel as a military adversary rather than an allied belligerent (keeping in mind that even Russia and China, enemies of America, “merely” aid enemy forces in targeting U.S. soldiers but don’t personally kill them)—the report was scuttled so the U.S. government would never see it. Worse still, the Times suggests this was a conspiracy designed in significant part to hide urgent intel from the federal authority with constitutional power over American military declarations: Congress. In other words, Milstein wanted to make sure Congress didn’t know that the Israelis were killing Americans, as this intel would have led to Congress blocking America’s continued involvement in the Iran War, or America ceasing to supply Israel with arms, or even America coming to treat Israel as an belligerent against us (as repeated killing of Americans may easily have suggested).
Milstein’s clandestine actions were so treacherous that they disrupted the daily operations of the most important American embassy in the continued conduct of the Iran War. Keeping in mind that the operations of the American embassy in Jerusalem immediately took on a “life-or-death” role when the Iran War began and American soldiers were in harm’s way, the Times reporting indicating that American diplomats in Jerusalem had to “refrain from writing reports for fear that Milstein would block or rewrite them” suggests that American lives were directly put in danger by Milstein’s treachery. Intel that never got to political agents in D.C. also never got to the Pentagon, to the United States Intelligence Community, or to those congressional committees in charge of military affairs.
What Did Huckabee Know, and When Did He Know It?
The Times gives Ambassador Huckabee some undeserved grace—writing that it’s still “unclear” how much he knew about what his top deputy was doing.
But the facts the Times reports make such willful ignorance beyond improbable, as the newspaper seems, at least implicitly, to be aware:
The Times notes that Huckabee is “a longtime advocate for the Israeli settlement movement.” This means Milstein would had no reason to hide from his boss that he was lying to Washington about Israeli settlements and violence by Israeli settlers, as his interest in doing everything possible not to threaten a “movement” he well knew his boss supported was co-extensive with his boss’s.
The Times acknowledges that Ambassador Huckabee is “required to sign off on most cables and significant decisions.” While it also notes that Milstein was “sometimes” known to act on his own, (a) “sometimes” is not “always” (meaning Huckabee was often involved in signing off on “significant” cables and decisions, which is exactly what the ones involved in the present scandal were), and (b) even if Milstein occasionally acting on his own accord on the front end, there’s simply no reason to believe his boss wouldn’t have discovered his conduct ex post and been in a position to reveal and sanction it had he wanted to do so. Yet for all that, there’s no evidence of Huckabee ever alerting the White House or Congress to what Milstein was doing.
The Times further concedes that Ambassador Huckabee “sometimes worked in concert with Milstein to suppress or recast information” (emphasis supplied). This is a proverbial “smoking gun,” as it means that Milstein knew that his boss knew what he was up to. Why? Because on many occasions his boss helped him do it. This reduces to zero or nearly zero the possibility that Milstein harbored any fear that he needed to hide his activities from his boss—even activities he might not have told his boss about on the front end, as at least on the back end he had every reason to believe Huckabee would back his play. He might even have felt his solus acts were guided by principles that he’d picked up directly from Huckabee those times the two actied in concert to betray America’s national security interests.
The Times says that Milstein “is one of the most senior officials in the embassy, acting as a chief of staff of sorts” to Huckabee (emphasis supplied). The idea of an experienced politician like Huckabee—who ran for President of the United States multiple times, and came in second in the race to become the Republican nominee once—not knowing what his own chief of staff was doing is, frankly, ludicrous. This is especially so given that, as the Times notes, what Milstein was doing was “unusual” and therefore much easier to catch. He not only “blocked reporting from being sent [to D.C.]” or “delayed approving drafts [of urgent memos] until the topic was no longer relevant”—events it would have been nearly impossible for his boss to miss, as they involved grave, ambassador-level emergencies—but would “rewrite cables to deliver a different—sometimes opposite—message from the original” (emphasis supplied). This isn’t just a firing offense but one that would repeatedly have wrongfooted the Trump administration as to facts on the ground… a wrongfooting that surely would have been vigorously pointed out to Ambassador Huckabee as an ongoing embassy issue (see infra for more on this).
The relationship between Huckabee and Milstein is clearly a tight one. Per the Times,
Earlier this month, after an article critical of Milstein for inviting wedding guests to give him money appeared in Politico, Huckabee posted on social media that he had “absolute confidence” in his aide, whom he said possesses “impeccable integrity.”
Huckabee here portrays himself as knowledgeable and approving of Milstein’s work as his deputy. He specifically wrote—voluntarily—about the issue of Milstein’s integrity, which was precisely the quality put in question every time Milstein betrayed America and aided Israel on an issue that was notably near and dear to Huckabee’s own heart.
For those wondering, the Times report is unusually thorough—as it comes from fifteen American officials who have worked with Milstein in his capacity as a top deputy of Ambassador Huckabee. That’s uncommonly robust sourcing for a news report that, in effect if not explicitly, establishes a political appointee as having committed Treason.
Moreover, all fifteen sources were afraid.
They believed they could face serious “reprisal” for revealing what Milstein was doing.
Nevertheless, their desire to defend the United States was such that they provided the Times with documents it never otherwise could have accessed (the Times got “dozens of documents, cables, memos and other internal communications” from its sources).
In other words, the sources all believed they were protecting the United States from a major national security breach.
Nor are these sources anti-Israel. The Times notes that all or nearly all of them are still ardently supportive of the U.S.-Israel relationship remaining strong.
Nor were the sources at all anti-Trump. In fact, most of them expressed grave concern about Milstein acting premeditatedly to “contradict the president’s stated policies”—in other words, America’s wartime policy. They viewed Mr. Milstein as undermining America’s commander-in-chief in the midst of a massive, bloody, ever-expanding war.
Why This Is Now a Donald Trump Pre-Election Scandal
It would be easy enough to report that this is now a major Trump pre-election scandal—one that will affect the midterm elections in a way deeply detrimental to the GOP—by arguing that the mere fact of Milstein being a top aide for Senate Republicans, and a Trump appointee, and working under Trump’s handpicked ambassador, and having never been reprimanded or stopped by either Huckabee or Trump (and, critically, it’s clear he still won’t be now) is enough to say that this scandal implicates Trump directly.
But the facts here are much worse than that.
Why? Because the Times says that the White House knew what was happening (emphasis added):
[S]enior administration officials in Washington, including in the White House…have expressed frustration to colleagues over some of Milstein’s actions, according to four officials, who have either witnessed or been briefed on the dissatisfaction.
And then there’s this even more specific piece of reporting (emphasis supplied):
Troubled by glaring discrepancies between news coverage and the embassy’s official reports, White House….officials seeking a clearer picture of events bypassed standard channels [that would have run through Mr. Milstein and Mr. Huckabee] at least twice to communicate directly with embassy staff, according to two officials briefed on the outreach and an internal communication from late this summer seen by the Times.
So the White House won’t be able to say, “No one here knew this guy was a problem.”
At best, it could say that (a) many here knew he was a problem, but (b) we didn’t know the extent of the problem, and (c) despite the core facts of the case seeming to amount to Treason against the United States in wartime—a federal felony that’s punishable by death—we hid every aspect of this scandal from the President of the United States.
But will Donald Trump go along with the idea that h was lied to for a year by his own employees on a national security matter of this gravity? In the midst of a war? Under circumstances establishing that we almost certainly still don’t know the full extent of what Milstein—and likely Huckabee—are hiding from the U.S. about the Iran War? All in service of a foreign country whose national security interests notably diverge from America’s, even according to Trump’s own administration-wide policy agenda?
No. Of course not.
Trump will—and based on his political persona, he must—do what he always does.
He must claim that either he knew about what Milstein was doing and saw no issue in it, or claim that he didn’t know what Milstein was doing because he was in fact doing nothing wrong and therefore there was nothing for his top subordinates in the White House to bring to his attention. This despite the fact that Trump confirmed to voters in February 2026 that the policy of his government was to “oppose annexation” in the West Bank, and that it was less than a month later that Milstein began hiding from him and other top White House officials that Israel was betraying that very directive (for as the Times notes, as of February 2026, Americans working at the embassy in Jerusalem would have known that Netanyahu’s policies were “speeding the way to annexation”).
All of which brings up a third possibility: Trump could double down and go much further than he needs to go by saying Milstein was doing as he was commanded to do by the president himself (despite the evidence clearly establishing exactly the opposite).
The problem here is that, with just three weeks until the midterm elections, none of these three Donald Trump “go-to” scandal responses will fly with American voters.
Why?
Because support for the Iran War is now down to 32%—less than a third of U.S. adults.
That’s the same popularity that “going to the opera” now has in the United States.
It’s also worth noting that the United States just commemorated the 25th anniversary of the September 11 attacks. The chief lesson of those attacks was that whenever U.S. officials ignore intelligence about imminent chaos emanating from the Middle East, Americans die—just as Israelis died because Netanyahu ignored 13 warnings from three countries about the impending October 7 attacks and had been bankrolling October 7 perpetrator Hamas (to the tune of $35 million per month) for many years.
With this in mind, maybe the most damning reporting on Milstein by the Times reveals that he “prevented [intel] reports from being sent as drafted”—despite those reports including ones that warned Washington of a “new Palestinian uprising” that other U.S. diplomats were convinced would arrive very soon because of Netanyahu’s actions.
Such an uprising (an intifada) would be a new global terror threat against Americans abroad—even Americans at home. It would be a threat on the order of warnings that another GOP presidential administration, the Bush II administration, ignored in 2001.
So Milstein’s premeditated plot to hide the possibility of a coming intifada from both the White House and Congress can be seen as at best the sort of callous conduct that led to September 11th and the deaths of nearly three thousand Americans, and then, at worst, what the evidence we now have more strongly points toward here: Treason.
What Happens Now
Faced with this massive scandal, the White House won’t even speak to the New York Times—which is itself astonishing and telling.
What the White House did, instead, is direct the Times to the State Department, which is a problem because…
…the State Department’s denial of the story—without making an attempt to contradict it with facts or evidence—implicitly underscores how devastating the story would be to the Republican Party if it were ever conceded.
And here’s what Ambassador Huckabee said (which, while not the official statement from Foggy Bottom, stands in for that given the terseness of the one Foggy Bottom issued): “The elements of the story the New York Times is trying to assemble are so lacking in fact that it ranks up with other Times farcical endeavors. I personally and categorically refute the elements of your proposed ‘story.’ ”
This is the response a government official gives when admitting the truth of a media outlet’s reporting would be devastating to his administration. It makes very clear that Huckabee didn’t feel he could say, “Yes, we did this—and it was okay for this reason.”
It also makes clear that Huckabee didn’t even think he could say, “I’ll investigate this, as these allegations are serious.” Instead, he appears to believe that the allegations—sourced, remember, from fifteen of his work colleagues—are so serious that he not only can’t concede their veracity but can’t even pretend he thinks (despite the fact that they imply Treason, possibly even by him) they warrant any internal investigation. Or even any discussion.
And as a former federal criminal investigator, I’ll state bluntly that I find this last fact the most compelling.
Huckabee had a chance to throw Milstein under the bus, either by admitting the allegations were true and relieving Milstein of his duties or, at a bare minimum, saying that the allegations were serious enough that they clearly merited further investigation. In Huckabee refusing to do either of these things, it turns an idea that the Times reporting already implicitly militates for—Huckabee is himself a Milstein co-conspirator, one animated by radical religious beliefs that are incompatible with American national security—into one that’s exponentially more likely.
Whether or not Huckabee actively participated in Milstein’s seeming Treason, there’s now every reason for federal criminal investigators to be concerned that Huckabee did know what was happening after the fact—at a minimum—and then chose not to stop it.
That his betrayal of his country was apparently grounded in his far-right Christian religious beliefs—when Republican voters and officials have for years torn their shirts over the prospect of Jews or Muslims betraying America in this way and for this reason—only makes the present situation more morally grotesque, particularly as to Trump’s unwillingness to do anything about it. Trump has routinely advocated for the death, imprisonment, and/or deportation of persons who are Jewish or Muslim and who he claims have betrayed America on that basis, though in fact such targets have never betrayed their country as the Christians Milstein and Huckabee now appear to have.
In short, Trump’s present inaction makes clear that he sees Christian nationalist-inspired Treason against the United States as broadly acceptable.
But it gets worse for Trump.
Milstein is the stepson of one of Trump’s top advisers, a man whose television show Trump admits to watching (forgive the pun) “religiously”: Mark Levin. The idea that Trump, who’s in regular contact with Levin, would have no idea what Levin’s stepson was doing allegedly on Trump’s behalf in Jerusalem simply isn’t to be credited. Nor, as noted above, should we assume that Trump will suggest otherwise—even as he can’t claim Milstein was advancing his policies (for we know he was doing the opposite).
Indeed, should Trump say that Milstein was doing his bidding, he will be making this scandal far worse. Why? Because he’d be admitting that he lied to voters about what America’s policy in Israel is; that that policy is in fact far more pro-Israel—and likely to provoke future American wars and combat deaths—than he’s ever wanted domestic voters to realize, and that he has no plans of changing course now that he, Huckabee, and Milstein have been caught hiding critical intel from Congress, American voters, the Pentagon, and leading members of the United States Intelligence Community.
Conclusion
One thing Proof looks for in the early days of a political scandal is whether every new fact makes it worse or better. For the big scandals, the movement is always clear: worse.
With that in mind, here are the ledes the Times buried (in its defense, perhaps because it had so many astonishing, even unprecedented ledes to choose from):
Milstein lived in Israel for years and studied at a yeshiva in Jerusalem, raising in reality fears about dual loyalty—based on the man’s background, public writings, and conduct—of exactly the sort Mr. Trump has often antisemitcally implied just from someone being Jewish;
Milstein is so powerful in Republican politics that he’s worked for almost every major Republican presidential candidate of the last decade (including Donald Trump, Ted Cruz, Mike Huckabee, and Ron DeSantis), making it impossible for anyone to portray him as a fringe figure;
despite being an American political appointee, he’s been caught telling many colleagues that if they’re not “pro-Israel” they’re effectively terrorists (when of course an American political appointee should only be “pro-United States” in the completion of official, taxpayer-funded duties);
this is Milstein’s second stint being a top deputy to a Donald Trump ambassador to Israel, as he also worked for Trump’s first-term ambassador (David Friedman), meaning that Trump chose to rehire the man and therefore can hardly suggest now that he knows nothing about him; and
the Times report strongly suggests Milstein was behind a potentially criminal conspiracy to Make False Statements to Congress—and not about a minor matter, either, but about the death of nine Americans at the hands of Israelis.
When Hillary Clinton allegedly failed to properly oversee the U.S. embassy in Libya, Republicans investigated her, and repeatedly threatened to imprison her—often using the justification that six Americans had died due to her supposed negligence—for six years. That’s right, the GOP investigated Clinton for six years for the Benghazi Affair.
The West Bank Affair is clearly exponentially worse. And carries a death toll that’s higher. And we’re three weeks out from an election in which a significant percentage of the voting population thinks Trump and his agents have been compromised by the Israelis, and that 23 U.S. military deaths and 1,000+ military casualties have been the result of this compromise.
This is a historically damning “October surprise” of a president’s party’s own making.




Seems that Trump's public open invitation to Iran to "take out" cities in Southern California ought to fall under the ambit of treason. If not, why not?
A yeshiva boy and a fundamentalist “waiting-for-the-Second Coming” goy—what could go wrong?